My Top 10 Qb's

Where's Antwan Randle El period....

Last I heard Redskins, back on the Steelers

Peyton Manning as #1 LOL, Thats gotta be the biggest joke ever

Here is why most people dont understand anything they say or type.

Peyton Manning

13 years in the league

11 Playoff appearences

9 first round Exits

2 super bowls

1 win

1 loss

peyton has certainly underperformed in the postseason no one can argue that

he is still the best QB in the nfl though no one has been so good for so long

if the colts get any kind of decent RB they will go along way in the playoffs this year

My point is its all about winning the big one, With all the hype happy feet (Manning) gets he is a proven playoff loser.

He is no Tom Brady, Joe Montana, Hes not even a Ben Rothlisberger.

Hes a Dan Marino with one superbowl and the only reason he has that one superbowl is because Rex Grossman was the QB of the other team.

Also, You dont like my opinion, Yet unlike yourself, I provided facts, You asked a silly question, what was my point, Next time you choose to engage an adult in a conversation, I suggest you come in with a little more than that please.

If I were to start a franchise and I needed to win right now:-

1) Tom Brady

2) Peyton Manning (can be alternated with Brady)

Then

3) Drew Brees

4) Aaron Rodgers (needs at least one more winning season to take Brees spot)

Then the bottown 5-10 is debatable

5) Big Ben - ONLY because he is a winner and has a lot of experience in big games, even though he rides his defense...

6) Michael Vick - like him hate him, he is a winner. Because of his unpredictability, coaches have a hard time designing a gameplan for him. Last season he showed A LOT of maturity

7) Philip Rivers - If he was that good, he would have won a ring now. Ok let not push it, but he would have taken his team deep into the playoffs, but he hasn't

8, 9, 10 - Romo/Eli/Ryan (thinking on top of my head - in no particular order).

Hmm, I would like to put Eli as 7th over Rivers but last season Eli threw 25 INTs. Still you'd expect him to do 4000yards 30TD / 15 Ints from hereon out. Into his 8th season, I guess he has some some upside...

Also, Schuab should be in the top 10 debate...